Critical Essay For Paul'S Case Story By Cather

Cather learns to love, and identify, again, and differently, reaching out to Paul across the gulf separating the butch lesbian author from the effeminate boy, in a way which critics such as Judith Butler and Christopher Nealon, as well as Sedgwick, have seen as potentially significant in marking a moment of a historical, as well as an individual’s affective shift, in which recognising a shared gay identity.(10) Away from gender toward sexual object choice.

To consider this realignment is to consider only one aspect of Sedgwick’s essay which contains so many more, including a lovely reading of my favourite Cather novel, The Professor’s House, in its final pages.

Sedgwick wryly points out to us that it is not quite the one you might suspect: “‘Insincerity,’ Cather writes, ‘Art that is artificial and insincere […] for which there is no forgiveness in Heaven, no forgetting in Hell’”.(4) As Sedgwick puts it, “The odd oversight of the framers of the Criminal Law Amendment Act and the 1885 Labouchère Amendment to it, in omitting to include by name the unspeakable crimes of artificiality and insincerity, doesn’t slow Cather a bit in this determined act of redefinition”.(5) According to Sedgwick, Cather repudiates Wilde’s effeminate art of the artificial in order to distinguish it, and him, from herself, and her own sincere, American, butch art, steeped in a prairie realism, resting firmly on a love of the natural.

Yet, as Sedgwick also points out, even as Cather disavows Wilde, she creates a space for some kind of awkward, future recognition of a shared sexual identity, a sort of off-hand, partially redemptive gesture toward the desires and acts which, when compared to the unspeakable aesthete’s sin of artistic artifice, are really not so bad as all that.

As Cather goes on to write: “‘The sins of the body are very small compared with that’”; with artificiality.

Sedgwick continues, in a careful and attentive reading, to show Cather’s apparent change of heart toward Wilde through her rendering of the adolescent, criminal, would-be Wildean aesthete, Paul, in Cather’s own favourite of her short stories, ‘Paul’s Case’ from 1905.

Pamela Thurschwell Department of English, University of Sussex P.

"Paul's Case" is set in Pittsburgh in the early twentieth century, when the city was a major American center for the production of iron, steel, and glass.

They are also keen representations of American identities, and examples of Cather's developing experimentation with narrative form.

These stories are therefore perceptive studies of urban settings.


Comments Critical Essay For Paul'S Case Story By Cather

  • Paul's Case” by Willa Cather Literary Fictions

    Mar 14, 2013. Paul's Case ~ A Classic American Short Story by Willa Cather written around. Issue 3 · Write to Meow 2014 ~ Anthology of Stories, Poems, Essays · Write to. It was Paul's afternoon to appear before the faculty of the Pittsburgh High. His mind, unable to cope with vital matters near at hand, worked.…

  • Homosexual Identities in Willa Cather's 'Paul's Case' - SAGE.

    Rubin's essay is also of its time in its refusal to consider the historical context of. tific” approach'.4 In keeping with the New Critical belief that great literature is. In '“A Losing Game in the End” Willa Cather's “Paul's Case”,' published in. that 'the complexity of Cather's story' and the 'perspective on homosexuality in it'.…

  • Willa Cather and Others - Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick - Resources -

    But, in this essay, she also some might argue, more centrally writes about Cather's 1905 short story, 'Paul's Case' in a way, which I think, is a. Her readings here exemplify why thinking through Sedgwick's criticism makes you cognizant of.…

  • Paul's Case by Willa Cather - Goodreads

    Paul's Case is a short story and probably not as famous as some of Willa Cather's other writings, but it stuck out to me because I could understand the character.…

  • Paul's Case - Studylib

    Paul's Case Essays and Criticism ♢ Heredity or Environment. Paul's Case Summary "Paul's Case" by Willa Cather is, as the subtitle states, "a study in.…

  • Paul's Case Documents Course Hero

    Willa Cather's Paul's Case Notes, Test Prep Materials, and Homework Help. Easily access essays and lesson plans from other students and teachers. information icon Upload your own study resources to earn free access to these documents! Paul's Case. edited Reaction And Critical edited Reaction And.…

  • Paul's Case Themes from LitCharts The creators of SparkNotes

    May 11, 2018. Need help on themes in Willa Cather's Paul's Case. That term is, in fact, a clue to how Cather wants to both explore and critique Paul's own.…

  • Why Willa Cather Revised "Paul's Case" The Work in. - jstor

    E. K. Brown, Willa Cather A Critical Biography New York Knopf, I953, p. I2I. 2 American. attempt to explain why Cather changed Paul's story a story not about an artist. this review because, first, with "Paul's Case" Cather attempts to.…

The Latest from ©